I'm new to Tribal Wars and had a similar experience: 2200 attacking troops (good mix of types) at 53% wiped out 1700 defending troops (also a good mix of types) at 140% while taking less than 1500 losses themselves. I'm not prepared to call this BS, but I do need to understand it better.
I am very disappointed in the battle report. It didn't have any detail about rounds of combat, what killed what when, or essentially anything that would let me learn from the experience. I'm new to Tribal Wars, but I've played some other games that had excellent battle reports - the kind that would let you (after enough battles) start to infer the actual algorithms, which is what I like. The wiki doesn't seem to cover combat in any meaningful detail either.
Am I missing something, or is a battle report where the "details" are nothing more than a summary of how many units were lost and revived all I have to look forward to in this game?